

Let me state my intentions first. This is not an attempt to sanitize other political parties or defame communism. I just want put forward some facts and my thoughts from those facts.
My dear leftist friends, hope you read this without any preoccupation or biased thoughts.
Starting from the latest Nuke deal and going back to the pages of history, it is vividly visible that the party is unable to modify its stands or principles based on the advance in technology. Also in these days the agenda of the party has become the agenda of a few at the top. Rule of oligarchy?
If you clearly go through the arguments against the deal, no concrete and rational statements can be found. Some are really absurd and might be valid in the stone age!! Some are just to find new markets in the minority vote bank.
- "The nuclear deal will harm small traders and farmers. It will be harmful to workers and sectors like insurance and banks, too. To protect farmers, we have to stop this deal. The nuclear deal is related to globalization and market economy". This is Mr. Karat's opinion. I tried hard to understand this but failed miserably. How can a party with such an ideology be behind the atrocities happened in Nandigram and Singur?
- Second argument was that the deal is against some minorities of India. This is too weak and ridiculous to come out from a national party. Of course the target is to gather more votes in the coming election. Oppose the USA- the new mantra
- We miss you Mr. Harkishan Singh Surjit, the great leader. I strongly believe that this man could have done something radically different at the present situation. The funniest part is that there are leaders within the party who support the deal. Mr. Basu, Mr. Somnath Chatterjee. Does anybody dare to tell that Congress could bribe these veterans to be pro-Deal? The strongest opposition was from Mr. Karat. I am still not clear why.
- Our leaders went to meet the Chinese communist leaders during their India visit. The advice received, " First national development, then ideology." Practical answer. Do ideologies provide food, clothes and shelter?
- Some leaders used to go to China for "Study". Then came back to India and continued to deliver the same old cliches in their speeches.
- There was a time when computers were against left principles. Later it was shamelessly accepted by the party protogonists as the biggest blunder. Later at time the same acceptance may be there regarding N-Deal also :)
Also rules in Kerala and W. Bengal are different eventhough both are led by the left.
Conflict between ideology and pragmatism will continue..........




